If you like the flavor and atmosphere of a NY style pizza joint, then this is the place to go. Decorated with a home town flare, the pizza is great and the staff is friendly. Would highly recommend.
Posted: 5/28/2008 • Last edited: 4/30/2009 • Link to this review
I recently visited Johnny NY pizza, "the worst". We ordered a meatball wedge, two slices, and garlic knots. The meatballs in the wedge were hard and burnt. The sauce on the slices was tart "disgusting". The garlic knots were cool, but how can mess up garlic knots. Please take the "NY" out of your name your doing NY a disservice. Just call yourself "pizza".
Posted: 2/17/2008 • Last edited: 4/30/2009 • Link to this review
We ordered a pizza from them last week that took over 2 hours to deliver (we are 3 miles away). After numerous calls regarding the order, they offered a free cheesecake. Once it finally arrived, we called back because it was ice-cold. They offered to comp our next meal. Well, we just called them (on hold 20 minutes)and there was no record of the promise. They offered a 50% discount and pretty much told us we were liars. Avoid this place!
Posted: 5/07/2007 • Last edited: 4/30/2009 • Link to this review
The food here varies - can be great, can be blah. The people can be friendly or surly. Some days they close at 11:00PM, other days 8:00PM. There is just no way to tell, I guess it depends on how they are feeling. I've purchased pizza from them at least 6 times in the past year and I am done with them now. Fellini's is right around the block and Johnny's need to stop being so unpredictable and start focusing on making people happy.
Posted: 6/15/2006 • Last edited: 4/30/2009 • Link to this review
I love Johnny's Pizza, but the service tends to vary. If I get delivery they was show up in 10 minutes or it make take over an hour and a half.
Posted: 12/13/2005 • Last edited: 4/30/2009 • Link to this review