If they were in Chicago, I would go to a different pizza place. But for Atlanta, they are by far the best Chicago style place. It is great by itself, but just don't compare it to the Chicago originals :)
Posted: 1/24/2011 • Link to this review
I have been to Nicolo's twice in the past couple of months after discovering this place through Restaurant.com. I have had quite a bit of Chicago deep-dish stuffed pizza in my time and this is the closest thing to Giordano's that you will find around here. Though it does take a while to prepare it is well worth the wait! Once slice will fill you up! Thanks Nicolo's! Looking forward to seeing you again real soon..
Posted: 8/17/2009 • Link to this review
Being from chicago truly enjoying traditional chicago style pizza, i was extremly happy to find this place! the food was incredible and the service was great as well.I definatly reccomend this place!
Posted: 6/11/2008 • Last edited: 6/12/2008 • Link to this review
Even though it may take 25-30 minutes to prepare the traditional Chicago style pizza served at Nicolos it's worth the wait. The wait staff was friendly, courteous and very attentive. We will be back soon and often.
Posted: 6/02/2008 • Link to this review
Everyone has there opinion these days, some good and some not so great. Unlike the other poor reviews, we actually like this place and the food is good. We have always had good service at this restaurant. It may not exactly be "Chicago", but it is the closest we have found in the ATL area. Some people these days are just hard to please. The deep dish pizza is pretty good, I prefer it over Pizza Hut and Dominos any day. I have also had there Vienna hot dogs, meatball sandwich (which is excellent)and have had there Italian beef as well (also very good).
Posted: 5/31/2008 • Link to this review
Some of the worst pizza I have every had. Italian sausage was good, thats all I can say for the place. Service was bad. I complained because the crust was doughy and not done and they at first did not want to do anything about it, but then when I asked to see the manager they at least knocked some off the price. It was also ridiculously expensive.
Posted: 5/30/2008 • Link to this review
I've only tried the pizzas so far, and they were all excellent. My favorites so far are the carnivore and the Alfredo. The honey mustard was also very good. The wait staff is very pleasant, and the owner's mother is simply adorable. She and her daughter make you feel right at home. This will definitely be a regular spot for my family and me to dine. I can't wait to try the calzones; I hear they are huge -
Posted: 5/08/2008 • Link to this review